That was surprisingly good! We usually don't do guided tours, but this was our only option to go to Catalina Island. However, the guide was friendly, except a short toilet stop no time at souvenir shop was wasted. We got to the harbor in Bayahibe soon, the Catamaran was nice as well, we were lucky that the used the sail, many of them just cruise with the engine. Snorkeling time could be a little longer and you had to carry a vest for security, but the coral wall was cool indeed and much more to see than the Bayahibe artificial reef. Buffet Food was okay, the grilled Pollo and meat quite good. Beach area on Catalina Island was good for a stroll, but about 2kms from the Bar the beach becomes private with no trespassing. In conclusion a very nice day trip. I don't know if we were one lucky group or the service stated in the other reviews got better! Would recommend!